Monday 24 March 2014

Divergent: Movie vs. Book

We all know I loved Divergent. I read it... like a year ago, I guess. Maybe more. Anywho, I loved it, finished it in a night. When I heard about the movie, I got pretty excited. I tend to get excited for movies.

I am extremely wary of book-to-movie adaptions after past bad experiences (Read: PERCY JACKSON MOVIES), but I have regained some hope after Catching Fire. So Holly, Lil, and I dressed up in the colors of different factions (Abnegation, Amity, and Erudite respectively) and went to the movie.

I was pleasantly surprised. No, it wasn't perfect. It wasn't amazing. But it was really good.

Divergent is a dystopian (post-apocalyptic, oppressive society-based) novel. Beatrice (Tris) Prior lives in the remains of Chicago some hundred years after the third world war. The city is split into five factions in an attempt to keep peace. Dauntless, who blamed cowardice for the war; Erudite, who blamed ignorance; Abnegation, who blamed selfishness; Candor, who blamed deceit; and Amity, who blamed aggression.

Tris is sixteen, and it is time for her to take the aptitude test, which will tell her what faction is best for her. Only it doesn't work. She is Divergent, someone who can be in more than one faction, someone who, in the government's eyes, cannot be controlled.

Tris has to hide her Divergence as much as possible to save her life. At the same time, she has to survive Dauntless initiation, go through boy problems, and possibly stop a full-scale war.

The movie did follow the main plot, which is the most important part. Events were out of order, and some things were changed (the almost final scene in the control room, Visitor's Day, Edward getting... oh, spoilers. Shh), but it was still clearly the same story.

The second most important part, the characters, was weaker aspect of the movie. Some were amazing. I liked Tris a lot in the movie, especially when Four was in her fear landscape. You go, girl. I thought Shailene Woodley did an excellent job portraying her. My favorite characters, however, were actually adults. Kate Winslet, who played Jeanine Matthews, was amazing. But Tris's mom, (Ashley Judd) was spectacular. I don't know how, but she was so convincing in everything she did. She was just likable and believable.

The major thing that disappointed me about the movie were the minor characters. Christina, Will, Al, and even Peter didn't get enough screen time, and not nearly enough character development. Peter, while a jerk, was not nearly the vicious, evil guy he is in the book. Christina and Will... they felt a bit flat, compared to the books. Al did not generate all the mixed emotions you feel in the book (pity, awkwardness, anger). Other characters didn't even make it in. Plus, Will, Al, and Peter (and this may just be me) ALL LOOKED ALIKE. So that was extremely confusing.

And then there was Four. Again, he did not generate the same emotions as he did in the book. In the book he shows a vulnerable side, which I love. You don't typically get a hero with vulnerability. It was awesome. In the movie, that's skimmed over. Also, I was bummed when I saw how Tris and Four reacted to Marcus at the end. In the book, it's dramatic and epic. In the movie, it's kinda lame.

Other assorted things: These are things that are more minor, but I notice. The setting, costumes, and music were all fantastic (except maybe the singing. The singing felt weird). The music when Dauntless was first introduced made me so happy. It just fit. I'm mad it's not on Spotify. Seriously.

I wish there had been more of the fun chatter that happened in the book. I know, time is an issue in the movie, but some dialogue in the book made me laugh.
(For example:
"I'm going to shoot a muffin off Marlene's head."
Or “What did you do, memorize a map of the city for fun?' says Christina.
'Yes,' says Will, looking puzzled. 'Didn’t you?”
And “Peter would probably throw a party if I stopped breathing.' 
'Well,' he says, 'I would only go if there was cake.”)
Plus, in a movie like this, it never hurts to lift the mood. To quote Joss Whedon, "Make it dark, make it grim, make it tough, but then, for the love of God, tell a joke." Not exactly the language I'd choose, but true nonetheless.
Here is my favorite part about the movie, if I'm being honest: They took a book with a romantic subplot, kept the subplot in it, AND THERE'S ONE KISSING SCENE IN THE WHOLE MOVIE. ONE. PRAISE THE LORD. A long one, yes, but still. (I dislike most kissing scenes, in case you can't tell. They're awkward to watch.)

So. I would rate it about the same as The Hunger Games, for me anyway, which is like 7 out of 10.